Add Your Own Review

Read more Reviews

Review: Old Star


Broadway, London, SW1H 0DB, United Kingdom

The Blue Boar's loss was the Old Star's gain

  • By SilverTraveller HMJ

    722 reviews

    Ribbon Ribbon Ribbon Ribbon Ribbon

  • May 2016
  • British
  • Casual
  • Yes
  • London
  • 10 to 15

40 people found this review helpful

I regularly meet an ex-colleague for lunch. As he’s still slaving away as a Westminster Civil Servant, time and venues are limited. However, today was the Queen’s Birthday (at least it was the privilege day that Civil Servants either take after the bank holiday or at a later date) and so we felt like splashing out.

The Blue Boar, claiming to offer ‘contemporary British dining in the heart of Westminster’, was our choice. It’s a little more expensive that our usual haunts, but ‘harassed worker’ is particularly partial to their Blue Boar Burger.

I arrived at 11.59am and after making myself known to staff, found a seat in the bar area and was presented with menus. In answer to the question, ‘can I get you a drink whilst you’re waiting?’ I said I’d check out the wine list and order a bottle. When harassed worker arrived, harassed and late, at 12.10pm, no one had been back to the table or was anywhere in sight and it was starting to get busy. We took an executive decision to leave and head across the road to an old favourite: The Old Star (OS).

Now normally, we’d have mac n cheese, but today we ordered what we’d being going to have in the Blue Boar: a burger and fish and chips. The prime steak burger (£15 in the BB) was £10.95 but was offered with a ‘free’ drink: pint of Peroni larger, beer, appletiser or coke. Bearing in mind we’d ordered wine, the offer was declined. My fish and chips (again £15 in the BB) was £10.95.

At the BB we’d have had a bottle of chardonnay, which I hate, but it’s the cheapest on the wine list at £27. At the OS, we had our favourite New Zealand Sauvignon Blanc for £25.

My fish and chips, served on a wooden board, were excellent. The batter was crisp and golden, the fish skinless and the chips served poking out of a paper chip-shop bag. With a portion of mushy peas and home-made tartar sauce in separate small dishes, I could ask for no more.

Harassed Worker didn’t finish his burger and proclaimed it to be a little dry – for £4 less, I could personally live with this.

The service was excellent (although you have to order at the bar upstairs the food is brought down to you) and as it was the Queen’s Birthday for Civil Servants, the place was empty and quiet.

All I would say is the Blue Boar’s loss was the Old Star’s gain. With the money we saved, we indulged in another cheeky glass of wine before he went back to the office and I headed home for a nap.

40 people found this review helpful

Did you find this review helpful? YES

This review is solely based on the opinion of a Silver Travel Advisor member and not of Silver Travel Advisor Ltd.

More about 'Old Star'

Why not read other articles and reviews possibly related to this one?
Read more

What are your thoughts?

Discuss this review on our Forum

Create a new thread To leave a comment, please Sign in

Other Members' Thoughts - 7 Comment(s)

  • ESW
    about 4 years ago
    That is better than nothing....
  • HMJ
    about 4 years ago
    I'm sorry!
  • ESW
    about 4 years ago
    Good for you - and what was the response?
  • HMJ
    about 4 years ago
    Adventurer and ESW - I am sure you will both be pleased to know that as we left, I went up to the bar and pointed out we were leaving as no one had been to serve us.
  • Adventurer
    about 4 years ago
    I agreed with you too.Why give them the business when there are better places elasewhere
  • HMJ
    about 4 years ago
    I think so too. If I'd been doing my Mystery Dining at the Blue Boar they'd have got dreadful feedback.
  • ESW
    about 4 years ago
    It sounds as if you made the right decision there.