A lifetime of walking boots

Date published: 04 May 21

109 people found this feature helpful

“How do they feel?” asked my grandmother, as she watched me march the length of the climbing shop.

“Fine,” I grunted monosyllabically. I was only 12 years old.

Granny nodded. “We’ll have these,” she declared to the shop assistant and pointed at the leather walking boots that were weighing down my feet. “They’ll last forever and will see him out.”

It was once thought that walking boots would last for life (Salinger)Granny was wrong, as my feet grew, the boots leaked and were soon replaced by others. Yet that was the understanding of the era. Walking boots would last for life and be with you to the end.

I now know differently. Granny’s shopping was followed by a lifetime of poor footwear, including a spell in the British Army, which seemed to feel that all feet were identical. One look at my shoe cupboard and a disorganised pile of mountaineering footwear falls out. Boots, trainers, approach shoes, even mountain sandals. My favourites are the trainers, as they are lightweight, should not leak but do, and carry the Quicklace system, which saves me tying a bow. One tug with ice-cold hands and the trainer is secure.

For a day’s walking in the mountains, especially when carrying a rucksack, my trainers struggle. Should that happen, on go my boots. I try to be lightweight, which means synthetic, as leather is generally heavy. Lightweights can wear out quickly, so I buy a new pair each year.

Now which do I wear today? Trainers (right) with their Quicklace system, lightweight boots (centre), or my faithful Scarpa Mantas (left).Be warned that lightweights can pong. I once spent six weeks crossing the Alps, from Geneva to the Mediterranean, and slept in many cramped mountain refuges. Walkers were usually on bunks. One night it happened.

“What is that terrible smell?” I heard a Frenchman say to his colleague. They were in a far corner of our crowded dormitory.

“Disgusting,” the colleague replied.

“Ugh!” exclaimed another.

“I’m going to be sick,” said a fourth, and headed for the door.

I lay in silence, feeling guilty. The smell was my lightweights, positioned under my bunk. You make no friends going lightweight, especially in a refuge.

The weight of footwear is important, as mountain lore has long declared that one pound on the feet is five pounds on the back. My two mountain trainers weigh 1.8 pounds (0.82 kg) and I barely realise they are on. My winter boots, with crampons, weigh 10 pounds (4.5 kg), a fifty-pound rucksack on my feet. I try to stay light.

Start by choosing your sock - bring your own when buying a new bootThere are no shortcuts when buying new boots, as a wrong fitting can be ruinous. The secret is not the boot, but the sock. I spend as long choosing the one as the other. My socks are woollen for sure, merino especially, with something man-made thrown in. This gives socks strength, allows them to stretch, as well as survive a washing machine.

Socks chosen, next the boots. I buy them in the afternoon, when my feet will be bigger, and I do not do a last-minute dash the day before a holiday. I know what design I seek before I enter the shop, and I choose an assistant who understands mountains.

For most, a boot should be flexible but not too bendy. If I seek full bend, I choose a trainer. I like a rand that covers the toe, while for the sole, Vibram is my favourite. This was named after Vitale Bramani who, in 1935, saw six of his friends slip to their deaths in the Alps, thanks to leather soles and hobnails. Bramani set to work and soon patented the sole now used worldwide. I go nowhere without Vibram.

I am a fan of the Vibram sole - look for the octagonal, yellow emblemThen comes the fitting, but I do not put on the boot. I remove the insole, lay it on the floor, and stand on it. I can instantly see if the boot might fit. I keep a forefinger’s width between the tip of my longest toe and the front of the insole, in case my foot slips forward when descending.

Then it is time for the boots. Back go the insoles, in go my feet, and the laces are tied in a jiffy. If it is fine, that is good. If not, no worries. I keep trying until I am happy. Next stop the mountains. 

However, perfect my boots, I still think blisters. At the end of a long march in the Army, we would be stood barefoot and to attention, ready for inspection. Anyone with a blister was punished.

Thanks to that experience, and before I pull on a sock, I coat a whisker of petroleum jelly on my foot. I then slither on the sock, wool on jelly, next the boot, tie the laces, and I’m done. Since jelly, I have never had a blister.

Thank you, Granny, for buying me those boots. Over decades, I have learned plenty.

If you want to buy walking boots

Choose your boots carefullyWalking boots are widely available, and you are spoiled for choice should you wish to buy any, so prepare to be confused. Whatever they tell you, do not expect them to last forever. I work on 1000 miles of walking before I need a new pair. Some are expensive, some are cheaper, and you do not always get what you pay for.

Some reputable brands include:

I wear Salomon Men's XA Pro 3D V8 GTX trail running shoes for daily exercise on my nearby fells. They are comfortable, but started crumbling less than two months after purchase, although I do spend a lot of time in the mountains.

When I crossed the Alps, I wore Scarpa R-Evo GTX boots. They were brilliant but did stink out the mountain refuges.

An icon of walking for over three decades is the Scarpa Manta. I have a pair. They are fantastic but slightly heavy by modern standards.

My favourite shops for walking boots are:
Cotswold Outdoor
Ellis Brigham

16 steps to boot-buying

  1. Take your time - buying walking boots is not a rushed process.
  2. Try the boots on in the afternoon, when your feet may be slightly swollen.
  3. Do not buy new boots the day before a walk.
  4. Start by choosing the sock, one pair only. Bring your own, not one offered by the shop.
  5. Decide if you want trainers, walking shoes, walking boots, or something for snow and ice. Most seek walking boots, especially if a rucksack is involved, or trainers if they are athletic.
  6. Ignore the question a shop assistant may ask, “Where are you going walking?” All walks are varied, and it is impossible to generalise.
  7. Lightweight or leather? Lightweight is normally synthetic, leather is heavier.
  8. How flexible is it? There is a B-rating of boots. B0 (fully flexible) or B1 are right for most. Try B2 or B3 (stiff as a board), if you wish to fit a crampon.
  9. Waterproof? Mine are. Think Gore-Tex.
  10. What type of sole? I am a fan of Vibram, which is used the world over.
  11. Be sure there is a rand, in case you stub your toe.
  12. Do they fit? Take out the insole and place it on the floor. Put your foot on the insole and assess the fit. You need a single finger’s breadth between the tip of your longest toe and the front of the insole.
  13. Replace the insole, try on the boot, and lace it up. Check the tongue does not press uncomfortably on the top of your foot.
  14. Walk up and down a slope to see how the boot feels.
  15. Try the boot at home but stick to carpet in case you need to return the boot.
  16. If all is well, next stop are the mountains.

More information

Top tips for choosing the perfect boot
Which walking boots are right for you?

See also

Fitting the perfect rucksack

109 people found this feature helpful

Did you find this feature helpful? YES
Enjoy reading other articles and reviews on this subject.
Read more

What are your thoughts?

To leave a comment, please Sign in

Other Members' Thoughts - 7 Comment(s)

  • JennieSilver
    about 1 month ago
    from a fellow walker: Many years ago when I first started walking, I was advised two pairs of socks. One Long and one short. These socks rub against each other and not your feet. The long ones cover the trousers, the short ones cover the top of the boots and stop stones getting in. In all the fifty years of walking NEVER HAD A BLISTER, and yes Vibram soles.
    Just thought I would mention this for newbies.

    Richard's reply:
    I have tried two pairs of socks on earlier occasions but did not meet with the same success as your good self but you are right, the system is advocated by a fair few fellow walkers and I am more than happy to have another go. I am out on the Langdales (Lake District) this very day, and am writing this just as I depart for the day, so guess what? I have two pairs of socks in place, one short, one long, and look forward to seeing how I get on. You’ll be aware, I know, of sock liners as well. They are a sort of upmarket version of what we are discussing. Again, I was not very successful with these but I confess that it was more likely me than the liners! There is quite a good blog about liners at https://www.greenbelly.co/pages/sock-liners. Thanks again for your comments, Gwen. Brilliant and well worthwhile. Best wishes. Richard V P.S. I do wish I could match your comment when you say that you have NEVER HAD A BLISTER. Sadly, I cannot!
  • RichardV
    3 months ago
    Thanks - for sure, walking socks make a huge difference. I am now hooked to the Bridgedale mid-weight Hike series. When I crossed the Alps I took two pairs. For weeks into the trip I was still on the first pair, which showed no sign of giving up. Purely because I felt it was reasonable, I binned the first pair after four weeks and donned my second pair, but in reality I did not need to do so. I think the longevity of my Bridgedales is thanks to their manmade content, in addition to the wool. But I sense socks are rather like mobile telephones. Whatever sock we wear, to each individual it is the best! Best wishes. Richard V
  • HanLong
    3 months ago
    Really enjoyable article. The boot section of any outdoor shop reminds me of trips there with my parents as a child excitedly trying on boots. I find myself quite drawn to walking socks these days but I am baffled by the huge choice and price ranges.
  • RichardV
    3 months ago
    Cheers. I have odd-sized feet as well, although it sounds to me as if your discrepancy may be larger than my own. I always err on the side of larger than smaller, as too small a boot plays Hell on my toes when I am going downhill. A thought, although judging from your past experiences, I'll wager you have already tried this. How about two socks on the smaller foot? One can purchase sock liners for this scenario. Perhaps our colleagues will have ideas that I have so far missed. Let's see. Best wishes. Richard V
  • keljimstock
    3 months ago
    Good article. Much useful info. However, I have always suffered from an apparently not uncommon problem. To wit - my fet are different sizes. My left foot is half a size bigger than my right foot which means that a pair of ordinary shoes will never be quite right for me. This of course is made worse when one is choosing a a pair of walking boots which will cover many miles of harsh terrain and stay on one's feet for many, many hours, even to the extent of having to sleep in them. One solution is to patronise an upmarket bootmaker who will craft a wooden pattern and then provide handmade boots ad infinitum. Minimum spend £5000 + . Ahem. The second is to buy two pairs of boots of different sizes and discard one pair. Again rather expensive. If anybody out there reads this and has constructive input to help me with my ongoing dilemma I should be more than pleased to hear from them. PS Yes I know. Find someone with rambling tastes and feet with opposite dimensions. But . . no luck so far.I do not know if such a thing is allowed on this site but my email address is [email protected]
  • RichardV
    3 months ago
    I could not agree with you more! What shames me, I guess, is that even after a zillion years of buying walking boots, I am still able to make a hash of it. When I look at my mountaineering colleagues on the hill, I note that they, too, sometimes have the same problem so am glad I am not alone. As you say, taking your time, and trying plenty, are essential. It pays, too, to do plenty of homework before you go anywhere near a shop. Thanks for taking the time to pass comment. Best wishes.
  • StillPlanning
    3 months ago
    Generally good advice for boots but there are other factors as well. The insole might give an indication of length and width, but volume, arch height and ankle width are also important factors. Different brands, and even the model and place of manufacture within a brand, add considerable variation. All these can make choosing boots a tricky and time-consuming process. So Tip 17 is: "Take your time and try a lot."